The 10 Best Eye Makeup Removers for You in 2023

The prettier the full glam makeup looks on the eyes, the harder it is to remove it, right? Eyeliner, mascara, and eye shadows when removed with a substandard makeup remover irritate the eyes and leave them looking dull. In addition, if you wear water-proof basic eye makeup in your routine, it is hard to remove it as well.

Although regular makeup removers can be used to remove eye makeup, they are not as gentle, efficient, and quick at cleaning off the eyes completely. So, a makeup remover specially designed for stubborn eye makeup helps in removing makeup without leaving residues behind.

So, if you are looking for high-quality eye makeup removers to help you take eye makeup off at the end of a tiring day, let me help you. I have devised a list of the best 10 eye makeup removers for eye makeup lovers in 2023.

So, let us get right into it.

Do Eye Makeup Removers Differ from Regular Makeup Removers?

Just like eye makeup is different from facial makeup, eye makeup removers are also different from regular makeup removers. Although both can be found in a liquid, cream, gel, or balm consistency, there is a subtle difference in the chemical makeup and use of both.

Regular makeup removers have a lower content of oil as compared to eye makeup removers. However, advanced eye makeup removers have oil-free formulations to remove stubborn makeup without making the skin greasy.

They are also more gentle because the eyes and skin around the eye area are sensitive. Additionally, eye makeup is tougher and more durable as it has to work on stubborn and waterproof eye makeup.

Some facial makeup removers can be used as eye makeup cleansers. But it is best to keep the eye makeup on because it can clog facial skin and lead to breakouts.

Best Eye Makeup Removers for You in 2023

Comparison Table

Here are our top picks in the category of the best eye makeup removers in 2023. You can find all of them easily on Amazon.

1. Lancôme Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover

The first and best rated in the list is Lancome Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover. It is one of the most trusted makeup removers when it comes to dealing with heavy eye makeup gently and easily.

This premium eye makeup remover has two phases, a water, and an oil phase. The oily phase contains lipids that cleanse the eye off makeup like mascara, eyeliner, and eyeshadows while the watery phase contains emollients that bind and remove makeup residues while leaving skin hydrated and fresh.

So, it ensures that your eyes do not have a speck of makeup or any impurities. Additionally, it is suitable for people with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.

2. Mary Kay Eye Makeup Remover

If oil-based makeup cleansers get too heavy for you and are difficult to take off, Mary Kay Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover can help you with its lightweight consistency and oil-free formulation. This affordable makeup remover comes in a serum form that can be easily applied to the eyes.

It does not irritate the eyes, clog the pores, or contain any fragrance. Moreover, it smoothly removes makeup from eyelids and eyelashes without pulling or tugging delicate eye skin.

This hypoallergenic eye makeup remover is also tested ophthalmologically and clinically to make it suitable for eye care and people who regularly wear contacts.

3. Neutrogena Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover

When it comes to makeup removers and skincare, Neutrogena is one of the top brands to go for. Its eye makeup remover does not disappoint either. Neutrogena Gentle Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover is a dual-phase oil-free makeup remover that removes eye makeup without making your eyes feel greasy.

Additionally, it contains cucumber and aloe vera extracts to nourish the skin after a long day. Also, it is so gentle on the eyes that it does not sting them, or tug eye skin. This drugstore eye makeup cleanser is formulated under dermatologists’ guidance and is also tested by ophthalmologists.

4. e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm

Although e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting balm is to cleanse facial makeup, its rich formulation and creamy consistency allow it to be used for cleaning water-resistant eye makeup as well.

This vegan, cruelty-free, fragrance-free, and toxin-free makeup balm contains ceramides and hyaluronic acid to help with skincare as it removes makeup. Additionally, it converts into oil and then cleanses milk as you rub it on the skin. So, first, it removes oil-based makeup and then nourishes the skin.

Moreover, it is easy to clean off from eyes and is compatible with all skin types.

5. Cetaphil Gentle Waterproof Makeup Remover

Cetaphil makeup remover is perfect for removing eye makeup gently with its liquid form and bi-phase formulation. Also, it is free of irritating fragrances, and greasy oils to help your skin stay soft and plump while removing difficult and long wear makeup without effort.

It contains ginseng, aloe vera, and green tea to soothe the skin and make this makeup remover suitable for sensitive skin and eyes. Additionally, it is tested and cleared by clinicians, dermatologists, and ophthalmologists.

So, if Cetaphil is your go-to brand, it is time to try its waterproof makeup remover on your beautiful eyes to keep them bright and healthy.

6. Maybelline New York Expert Eyes Oil-free Eye Makeup Remover

Maybelline New York Expert Eyes Makeup Remover is a moisturizing and non-irritating makeup remover for mascara, eyeliner, and other eye makeup. It comes in two options, a blue oil-free makeup remover, and a pink moisturizing makeup remover.

Both of them gently wash away eye makeup and make the skin around the eyes supple and hydrated. The blue one is in an oil form while the pink has a creamy texture. Moreover, both of them do not have any fragrance.

All you need to do is damp your cotton pads in this makeup remover and gently press on the eye while moving it in a circle to cleanse off makeup.

7. Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover for Eyes

If you are looking for a 2 in 1 product that helps in taking off the makeup from your lips in addition to the face, Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover is for you. Its non-toxic, benign, and cruelty-free formula can be used on delicate eyes and lips skin.

Moreover, it does not tug on the skin, irritate it, or sting the eyes. So, you can use it to remove your long-lasting waterproof eye makeup effortlessly. Also, it is tested by ophthalmologists making it safe for contact lens wearers.

8. Marcelle Gentle Eye Make-Up Remover Pads

Marcelle Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads are Amazon’s choice for the best eye makeup removers. It is because of the feasibility of the use of these non-greasy eye makeup remover pads, their soothing ingredients like aloe vera and cucumber, and their hypoallergenic, paraben-free, and fragrance-free formulation. So, they are suitable for people who wear contacts and have sensitive skin.

Moreover, the residues can be easily washed with warm water. These pads also come in two options, one with an oil-free formulation while the other is for waterproof eye makeup. So, these are the perfect and hassle-free eye makeup removers at the end of your day.

9. NIVEA Double Effect Eye Make-Up Remover

If you are a fan of recyclable products, Nivea Double Effect eye makeup remover is just right for you with its 96% recyclable bottle. It contains sunflower extracts, cornflower extracts, and seeds oil to nourish the skin. Additionally, its makeup-dissolving ingredients are also easy on the skin and remove the makeup effectively.

So, this bi-phasic eye makeup remover ensures that it helps you with stubborn and waterproof eye makeup while maintaining the health of your beautiful eyes. Moreover, make sure to shake the bottle before use to mix up its water and oil phase uniformly.

10. Eye Makeup Remover Liquid by Almay

Eye Makeup Remover Liquid by Almay is a premium dual-phase eye makeup remover enriched with cucumber, green tea and aloe vera. So, it works to remove mascara and eyeliner from the eyes in a few swipes without making you look like a panda. Moreover, it is a clean product packed in sustainable packaging.

It is also hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, cruelty-free, dermatologists tested and ophthalmologists tested. So, your eyes will thank you for selecting this product.

Conclusion

It is recommended to use makeup removers specifically designed for delicate eye skin and sensitive eyes so that they do not tug or pull the skin and sting the eyes. So, in this article, I have provided my top 10 suggestions for the eye makeup remover of 2023 along with the details of each.